The U.S. state of California has rejected a one-time 5% tax on the wealth of billionaires. The proposal, which was projected to generate tens of billions of dollars for public coffers, met with fierce opposition from tech magnates. Some chose to relocate rather than risk tax liabilities running into the billions.
• Google co-founder Sergey Brin even invested $102 million into the political fight against the proposal.
• However, not all the wealthy seek to minimize their tax burden; Warren Buffett and other billionaires have long argued that the richest Americans should pay significantly more in taxes.
American billionaires have received another lesson in just how sensitive an issue the taxation of their wealth can be. In a referendum held on November 3, California voters rejected a proposal to introduce a one-time 5% tax on the wealth of billionaires, with 52.8% voting against it and 47.2% in favor.
Consequently, California will not become the first U.S. state to implement a modern, one-time tax on the net worth of its wealthiest residents. The proposal itself, however, triggered an exceptionally strong reaction from segments of the tech and investment establishment.
Even before the vote took place, some billionaires began moving their primary residences out of California. Others invested vast sums into a campaign aimed at blocking the proposal. This story is not just about California. It raises a much broader question: Should the wealthiest individuals pay higher taxes on their assets, or is such taxation so risky that it could ultimately deprive state budgets of revenue that would otherwise be collected through income and business taxes?
Interestingly, there is no consensus on this issue—even among billionaires themselves.
Five percent of net worth: California sought tens of billions of dollars from billionaires
The proposal, known as Proposition 40, envisioned a one-time tax on the net assets of individuals who were tax residents of California as of January 1, 2026, and whose net worth reached at least one billion dollars.
The tax was set at five percent of net assets. It was not an annual levy, but rather a one-time tax.
The tax would have applied to assets such as stocks, corporate stakes, investments, financial holdings, art collections, and intellectual property. Direct ownership of real estate, as well as pension and certain retirement accounts, were generally to be excluded from the calculation.
The tax was due in 2027, with taxpayers given the option to spread the payment over five years, subject to specific conditions.
The proposal would have affected approximately 200 to 260 California-based billionaires, depending on the valuation method used for their assets. Proponents anticipated that it would generate revenue in the tens of billions of dollars. The economic analysis associated with the proposal’s authors projected a figure exceeding $100 billion.
The majority of the proceeds—specifically 90 percent—was intended for healthcare. The remaining ten percent was earmarked for education, food assistance, and administrative costs.
Proponents of the proposal argued, in particular, that it was necessary to offset cuts to federal healthcare funding. They contended that, at a time when millions of ordinary Americans are facing rising living costs and uncertainty regarding health insurance, those whose wealth has grown exceptionally in recent years should contribute more toward the funding of public services.
California’s Legislative Analyst’s Office confirmed that the tax could generate temporary revenue in the tens of billions of dollars, spread out over several years.
Counterarguments included the point that a one-time influx of revenue would not resolve the state’s long-term budgetary challenges. Furthermore, there was a risk that some of the wealthiest residents might change their tax residency, causing California to lose out on their future tax contributions.
Billionaires have spent hundreds of millions of dollars against the billionaire tax
The very scale of the political struggle is interesting. According to a CalMatters analysis, spending by opponents of Proposition 40, including related ballot initiatives, totaled about $378 million. Opponents thus had roughly ten times the resources compared to the main camp supporting taxation of billionaires.
One of the most prominent figures in the entire conflict was Google co-founder Sergey Brin. He put $102 million into the Building a Better California political committee, which led opposition to the proposal.
This is an extraordinary amount even by American standards. Brin thus became one of the most important individual financial actors of the campaign.
According to a Los Angeles Times analysis, however, the amount Brin put into the political fight represented less than one percent of his potential tax liability.
Other technology and investment entrepreneurs also joined the opposition to the proposal. Important contributors included, for example, Peter Thiel, Eric Schmidt and Chris Larsen.
Their argument was based primarily on the fear that a one-time property tax could cause investors, entrepreneurs and capital to leave California.
Opponents also pointed to complications in valuing private companies, shares, art objects and other assets that do not have an easily ascertainable market price.
California Governor Gavin Newsom also opposed the proposal. His argument was, among other things, the risk that a one-time tax would not bring a long-term solution to budgetary problems and at the same time damage the state’s economic position.
The result of the vote ultimately brought victory to the opponents of the proposal.
Interestingly, the backlash was not exclusively a Republican affair. Some prominent Democrats and organizations that otherwise support public health or education also opposed the proposal.
Google, Florida, Nevada. Who left California
Even more interesting than the campaign itself is the story of billionaires who decided to change their residence. The most prominent examples are the two co-founders of Google, Larry Page and Sergey Brin.
Google co-founder and former CEO Larry Page has moved his tax residence from California to Florida. According to Forbes, he purchased two luxury properties in Miami, Florida, worth a total of approximately $173 million.
The media estimated that if the proposal were to go through and Page were to remain a California resident, his potential tax liability could exceed $11.6 billion.
Sergey Brin, the second of the founders of Google, headed to Nevada, specifically to the Lake Tahoe area. He also changed his voter registration and moved his tax residence outside of California, according to media reports.
Its potential tax savings were estimated at around $11 billion.
At the same time, Brin is extremely interesting in that he was not satisfied only with a change of residence. As already noted, he invested $102 million in the political fight against the proposal.
Another notable example is Peter Thiel, co-founder of PayPal and an investor also associated with Palantir.
Thiel has owned real estate in Miami since 2020, changed his voter registration to Florida in 2024, and announced his retirement from California in late 2025. He also opened a family investment office in Miami.
He could allegedly save approximately $1.7 billion in taxes.
Other wealthy individuals who have been mentioned in connection with a possible departure from California include:
• Don Hankey, auto finance entrepreneur – potential tax savings of approximately $525 million.
• Lynsi Snyder, owner of the In-N-Out Burger chain – approximately $365 million.
• Meg Whitman, former head of eBay and Hewlett-Packard – approximately $220 million.
• Travis Kalanick, co-founder of Uber – approximately $180 million.
It should be emphasized that these are estimates of potential tax liability, not the amounts that these people have proven to have actually saved. Likewise, it cannot automatically be claimed that each of them changed their residence solely because of the upcoming tax.
Zuckerberg bought a house in Florida, but ultimately stayed
The case of Mark Zuckerberg—founder of Facebook and head of Meta—is also noteworthy.
Zuckerberg and his wife purchased an exceptionally luxurious property in Florida, valued at approximately $170 million. Consequently, his name also surfaced in discussions regarding a potential departure from California.
In the end, however, he reportedly remained a California resident.
His situation demonstrates that merely purchasing a property in another state does not automatically constitute a change in one’s tax domicile. Yet, it was precisely one’s tax residency as of a specific cutoff date that was crucial under Proposition 40.
Thus, Zuckerberg was among the wealthiest California entrepreneurs who would have faced an exceptionally high tax burden had the proposal been adopted.
How much revenue could the state lose?
This is one of the most fundamental economic questions surrounding the entire debate. On one hand, there was the prospect of a one-time windfall exceeding $100 billion. On the other, there was the risk that the wealthiest residents might relocate their tax residency elsewhere.
In its analysis, California’s budget office noted that the potential departure of billionaires could reduce state income tax revenue. It estimated this shortfall to be less than $1 billion annually.
However, this is merely an estimate, not a precisely calculated future loss. The crux of the problem lies in the fact that a significant portion of tech billionaires‘ wealth consists not of cash, but of stocks and equity stakes in companies—assets whose value can fluctuate dramatically over short periods.
A billionaire with a net worth of $100 billion may not have billions of dollars sitting in a bank account that could be easily used to pay taxes. Furthermore, selling a large volume of shares could diminish their influence within the company.
Conversely, proponents of such a tax argue that the very fact that a large share of the wealth growth experienced by the ultra-wealthy is not taxed on an ongoing basis—unlike ordinary income—justifies the introduction of a wealth tax.
From an economic perspective, this represented a clash between two distinct views on the fair distribution of the tax burden and the competitiveness of individual nations.
Buffett Calls for Higher Taxes
Adding a unique dimension to this narrative is the fact that some of the world’s wealthiest individuals have long advocated for higher taxes on the rich.
Rather than opposing tax hikes, they themselves argue that the wealthiest Americans should contribute more to public coffers.
One of the most prominent figures to take this stance is investor Warren Buffett. The legendary investor and head of Berkshire Hathaway has long been a critic of the American tax system.
In August 2011, he published an op-ed in *The New York Times* titled „Stop Coddling the Super-Rich.“ In it, Buffett pointed out a paradox that he believed characterized the American tax system: his own effective tax rate was lower than that of his office staff.
According to his own figures, in 2010 he paid approximately 17.4 percent of his taxable income in income taxes and related levies, while his office employees paid between 33 and 41 percent.
Buffett noted that wealthy investors derive a significant portion of their income from capital gains, which can be taxed more favorably than ordinary wages.
He therefore publicly urged the U.S. government to increase the tax burden on the wealthiest segment of the population.
In another public appearance in November 2010, he stated that individuals at the top of the income spectrum—himself included—should pay substantially higher taxes.
Buffett thus represents a rather unusual example of a billionaire who not only accepts higher taxation on his own income but actively calls for it.
Bill Gates and his father: The rich should contribute more
Another interesting example is offered by the Gates family. In 2010, Initiative 1098 was debated in Washington state to introduce a progressive income tax for the wealthiest residents.
The lawyer and philanthropist William H. Gates Sr., father of Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, was behind the proposal.
The proposed tax was to apply to incomes exceeding $200,000 per year for individuals and $400,000 for married couples.
Gates Sr. argued that Washington State’s tax system is unfair because relatively more of the tax burden is borne by low- and moderate-income households.
Its goal was to obtain additional funds for education and health care, but at the same time reduce some taxes for ordinary households and small businesses.
Interestingly, the proposal was also supported by his son Bill Gates, then one of the richest people on the planet. Bill Gates and his father were among the prominent figures who publicly supported higher taxation of the richest residents.
The initiative ultimately failed in the elections. About 64 percent of voters voted against.
Still, the story is an interesting historical example of how, even in the American technology environment, opposition to higher taxes was not unanimous among the wealthiest entrepreneurs.
George Soros supports higher taxation of wealth
Another prominent figure is the investor and philanthropist George Soros, who has long supported a more progressive tax policy and has publicly spoken in favor of higher taxation of the richest.
Soros is among the personalities who advocate for a greater contribution of the wealthiest layers of society to the financing of public services. His positions are also interesting in the context of broader academic research on billionaires‘ public statements on property taxes.
A study published in October 2026 analyzed the public opinions of one hundred of the richest billionaires from democratic countries between 1996 and 2024.
The researchers found that among the most prominent proponents of wealth taxation were Warren Buffett, Bill Gates and George Soros.
Together, these three men accounted for 38 of the 61 recorded public statements supporting property taxes.
At the same time, the study showed that the public statements of billionaires on this topic have changed over the years. After the financial crisis in 2008, support for higher taxation was more pronounced, while in later periods, negative opinions also increased.
It is important to distinguish between public support for higher taxation and the actual tax behavior of individual persons. One does not automatically prove the other.
The rich against the rich. A dispute that never ends
The California referendum showed how complicated the subject of taxing large estates is.
On the one hand, there is the argument that the wealthiest people benefit from the growth in the value of stocks, companies and investments, without this growth always being reflected in their ordinary taxable income. Proponents of higher taxation therefore argue that it is necessary to find a way to ensure a fairer contribution of the wealthiest to the funding of public services.
On the other hand, there is the concern that excessively high property taxes may lead to the departure of investors, entrepreneurs and capital to more tax-friendly jurisdictions. While the state may receive extraordinary income in the short term, it may lose part of tax revenues and economic activity in the future.
In addition, the Californian case showed how important a role billionaires themselves can play in American politics. Sergey Brin and other businessmen were able to put hundreds of millions of dollars into the campaign to prevent the passage of a proposal that would directly affect them.
But the story of Warren Buffett, Gates and Soros also reminds us that even among the richest Americans there is no unified opinion on how their property should be taxed.
California ultimately said no to the proposal. However, the debate on wealth taxation of billionaires did not end there. Unions pushing Proposition 40 have already conceded the possibility of returning to a similar proposal in 2028.
